Hotel reviews and advocacy, how to earn, answer and use them
Reviews report on your whole operation, not your marketing. Ask every guest, answer every review and show the real score, because UK law now expects it.
We recently traced a one-star review back to a sign-up form on a website. The form sent its enquiries to an inbox nobody checked. Nobody replied, and the person who had filled it in did the one thing still in their control. They wrote a review.
Nothing in that chain was a marketing failure, and every part of it ended up in the marketing.
That is how I think about reviews now. Earn them by asking every guest in the same way, with no incentive and no filter. Answer all of them, the good ones included, with the next guest in mind. Show the real score on your own website rather than a highlight reel, and report threats rather than paying them off. Since 6 April 2025 that is not only good practice in the UK. Most of it is the law.
This guide covers each of those, and the question underneath them, which is who in your hotel actually owns reviews. It is work our Growth Marketing practice does alongside the email, CRM and direct booking side, because that is where reviews are asked for and where their effect turns up.
Why reviews decide bookings
A guest choosing between three hotels in the same street has your photographs, your rates and your description, all of which you wrote. Reviews are the only part of the decision written by someone who has stayed. That is why guests trust them more than anything you say about yourself, and why they read them on Booking.com, Google and Tripadvisor before they get anywhere near your booking engine.
The weight falls hardest on independents. A branded hotel borrows trust from the name above the door. An independent without much brand awareness has to earn it from strangers, one stay at a time, and its reviews are most of the evidence a first-time guest has.
Guests also read reviews in a particular way. I still go straight to the one-star reviews before I book anything. I am not looking for a perfect score. I am looking for what goes wrong, and how the business behaves when it does.
A guest reads your reviews to find out what happens when something goes wrong, so your replies are part of the evidence.
There is a newer reason too. Reviews are no longer read only by people. Google summarises them, and AI assistants absorb them into the answer they give when someone asks where to stay.
Every review you leave unanswered is a reply the next guest reads anyway.
You cannot edit that story directly. You can change what it is built from, and reviews are a large part of it.
The rules since April 2025
The Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 made a set of review practices "banned practices" from 6 April 2025. The Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) set out what that means in its fake reviews guidance, and the CMA can now fine a business up to 10 per cent of its global turnover without going to court first. In March 2026 it opened its first investigations into review practices under the new rules.
Most of what the law covers will sound familiar to anyone who has read the platforms' own policies. The difference is that breaking a platform's rule costs you your listing, and breaking these costs you money.
- Fake reviews. Writing, buying or commissioning reviews that do not reflect a genuine experience, positive or negative.
- Staff and owner reviews. A review written by an employee, owner or supplier without saying so can count as a concealed incentivised review.
- Hidden incentives. A review given in exchange for a discount, upgrade or free night has to say so, and still has to be genuine.
- Cherry-picking. Inviting only satisfied guests to review, or showing only the good reviews, can mislead, according to the guidance.
- Buying silence. Offering a refund on condition that a guest does not review, or changes a negative review, is listed as an example of what not to do.
The previous version of this article recommended a tool that sent feedback requests after a stay and helped stop negative feedback reaching the review sites. It was common advice in 2023. It is not advice we would give now.
Google's policy on user contributed content bans incentives for reviews of any kind, and bans businesses from discouraging negative reviews or selectively asking for positive ones. It also says staff should not be set targets for a number of reviews. Under undertakings Google gave the CMA in January 2025, a UK business caught boosting its rating with fake reviews can have a warning shown on its profile and its reviews switched off.
Tripadvisor
Tripadvisor lets owners encourage reviews but not reward them, and its guidelines treat sending unhappy guests to a support channel instead of a review page as gating. Penalties run from removing the reviews to a warning badge on the listing.
Booking.com
Booking.com only accepts reviews from guests who booked through it and stayed, and it invites them itself. Your score is the average of the last 36 months of overall scores. You cannot remove a review, but you can reply to any that has written comments.
Getting more reviews, honestly
The volume of reviews is mostly a question of whether you ask, and how consistently. The honest method is also the one that works, because a steady flow of recent reviews from ordinary stays is what both guests and platforms trust.
Ask every guest, the same way
Send every departing guest the same invitation, whatever they told reception at checkout. The post-stay email is the natural place for it, and our guide to the post-stay email covers what else that email should do. Asking at the desk works too, as long as the staff ask everybody and not only the couple who were delighted with their room.
Asking everyone feels risky. It is the only version that is safe, and the occasional unhappy review it brings in is the price of a score people believe.
Catch the problem before checkout
The best review strategy has nothing to do with reviews. Give guests an easy way to raise a problem while they are still in the building, through a message, a call to reception or a manager who checks in on the second morning. A problem fixed mid-stay rarely becomes a one-star review. A problem the guest only gets to mention afterwards often does.
Service recovery belongs during the stay, not in place of the review.
Make it easy to leave one
Every extra tap loses reviewers. Link straight to the review form for each platform rather than to your listing, and keep it to one or two platforms per message so the guest is not asked to choose. Google is usually the one to prioritise for direct bookings, because it sits beside your name in search and on Maps, and our guide to Google Business Profile for hotels covers the rest of that profile.
Incentives and staff targets
Do not offer anything in return for a review on Google or Tripadvisor; both ban it outright. UK law allows incentivised reviews if they are clearly disclosed, and the CMA guidance says a prize draw is unlikely to count as commissioning a review, but that does not change either platform's rules. Bonuses for staff based on review counts sit badly with Google's policy too. Reward the team for the scores guests give, not for the number of reviews they chase.
Answering reviews well
A reply to a review has two readers. The reviewer, who has usually made up their mind, and every guest who reads it afterwards, who has not. Write for the second one.
That changes the goal. You are not trying to win the argument with the reviewer. You are showing a stranger how this hotel behaves when a stay goes wrong, which is the question they came to the one-star reviews to answer.
How to answer a bad review
- Wait before you write. Read it, then leave it for a few hours. Replies written in anger read as angry, typos and capital letters included, and they stay up as long as the review does.
- Get the facts from the team. Find out from whoever was on duty what actually happened before you respond, so the reply is not written blind.
- Thank them and acknowledge how they felt. You can say you are sorry the stay fell short without agreeing with every detail of their account.
- Explain once, without arguing. If something needs correcting, correct it plainly and briefly. Never call the guest a liar, and never get drawn into a second round.
- Say what has changed. If the complaint was fair, say what you have done about it. That line does more for the next guest than any apology.
- Take it offline. Give a name and a way to get in touch so the rest of the conversation happens privately.
A bad review is rarely meant as a personal attack, though it can feel like one, particularly in a small hotel where the owner is also the person on the desk. Usually the guest felt nobody listened at the time. A calm public reply is often the first sign that someone has.
The reviewer has usually made up their mind. The reply is written for the guest who has not.
Answer the good ones too
Hotels are good at apologising and oddly shy about saying thank you. Reply to positive reviews as well, briefly and specifically, mentioning the thing the guest enjoyed. It shows the next guest that someone reads every review, not only the painful ones, and a balanced page of replies is more convincing than a page of apologies.
Drafted replies help with volume, as a starting point. A reply that is obviously pasted, word for word, under twenty different reviews tells the reader nobody really read them.
What a reply must never contain
Platform rules on replies are strict, and Tripadvisor's are typical. Do not name the guest or include anything that identifies them, including their room or booking details. Do not include promotions, offers or compensation in the public reply; anything you offer goes in the private conversation. Keep it relevant to the review, and keep it polite even when the review is not.
Threats and extortion
Most hotels will meet a guest who uses a review as a bargaining chip at some point. Some will now meet people who have never stayed at all.
When a guest threatens a bad review
Tripadvisor treats a guest threatening a negative review to get a refund, an upgrade or anything else of value as blackmail, and it lets owners report the threat before the review is posted, through the Management Centre. Report it straight away, with the guest's name, email address and dates of stay, and keep every message as evidence. If a matching review arrives, Tripadvisor can then investigate it rather than publishing it straight away. If it is already live, report it anyway and post a short, professional reply while it is looked at.
A guest who says they will mention a broken shower in their review is not blackmailing you. They are telling you what happened. Fix the shower.
Review extortion scams on Google
A newer pattern hits Google profiles. A cluster of one and two-star reviews arrives from accounts that have never stayed, followed by a message offering to remove them for a payment. Google's advice is not to pay or engage, to screenshot everything, and to report it through the form on its review extortion help page.
Resolving a complaint without buying silence
You can still refund a guest, upgrade them or invite them back. What you cannot do is make it conditional on the review. The CMA guidance gives offering a refund in exchange for removing negative comments as an example of what is banned, and it warns against making any resolution depend on a guest not reviewing. Resolve the complaint because it was fair, and leave the review to them.
Using reviews on your own website
A guest who leaves your site to check you on Tripadvisor may not come back to book. Some will book on the OTA listing beside the reviews instead. Putting reviews on your own site keeps that research where the booking engine is, which is why it belongs in our guide to hotel website conversion as much as here.
Show the score, not a highlight reel
The CMA guidance applies to a business publishing reviews of itself on its own website, and it names selecting only favourable reviews, or highlighting positive ones that do not reflect the overall picture, as misleading. Show a live score from a named platform, with the number of reviews behind it. If you also feature individual quotes, choose ones that reflect what most guests say, and link through to the full set.
A live score built on a thousand reviews persuades more than ten hand-picked quotes.
Stars in search and claims in ads
Adding review markup to your own pages will not put stars in Google's results. Google's review snippet documentation says businesses that control the reviews about themselves are not eligible for review stars on their own pages. The stars guests see come from Google's own reviews and third-party sites.
The same honesty applies to ads. Rankings move, so a claim like "number one in the city on Tripadvisor" needs checking every time it runs, not once when the copy was written. "Rated in the top ten" that stays true is worth more than "number one" that was true in June.
Advocacy beyond the review site
Guests who post photographs of their stay are doing some of your marketing for you. If you want to reuse one on your website or your own channels, ask first and credit them, because the post is theirs. And if anyone has been given something for posting, from a free night to a paid partnership, the post has to say so; the same law covers it.
Turn reviews into decisions
Read together, a few hundred reviews tell you more than any guest survey. Sort them by theme (breakfast, noise, beds, check-in, value) and count how often each comes up, good and bad. That is where the next capital spend should go, and it is also the copy for your website, because the things guests praise unprompted are the things the next guest wants to hear.
Who owns reviews in your hotel
In most hotels, reviews belong to everyone and therefore to nobody in particular. Operations creates the experience. Reception decides who gets asked. Marketing sends the email. The website team shows the score, the agency writes the ads, and the general manager answers the worst reviews late at night.
Each of those can be done well on its own and still produce the one-star review at the top of this article. It came from a gap between a form, an inbox and a reception team, which is where most of them come from.
- One owner. Name one person responsible for reviews across every platform, with the authority to chase other departments.
- One response time. Agree how quickly every review gets an answer, good and bad, and check it monthly.
- One monthly read. Share the themes with operations, not only the score with the board.
If you change one thing this week, make it the review invitation. Every guest should get the same one, whatever they said at checkout. If yours currently depends on how the stay went, that is the first thing to fix.
Questions hotels ask
Yes, ideally to every review with written comments, good and bad. A reply is read by every future guest who sees the review, so it is one of the few chances to show how the hotel behaves when something goes wrong. Short, specific thanks for positive reviews show that someone reads them all.
Yes. Asking guests for reviews is allowed, as long as you ask them all rather than only the guests you expect to be happy, and you do not predetermine what they say. Since 6 April 2025 the DMCC Act bans fake reviews, concealed incentivised reviews and publishing reviews in a misleading way, including cherry-picking positive ones.
Not on Google or Tripadvisor, both of which ban incentives for reviews of any kind. UK law allows incentivised reviews only if the incentive is clearly disclosed and the review is still genuine, but the platforms' own rules are stricter, so in practice the answer for those platforms is no.
Do not give in to the demand. On Tripadvisor, report the threat through the Management Centre before any review is posted, with the guest's details and dates of stay, and keep every message as evidence. For a wave of fake reviews followed by a demand for payment on Google, report it through Google's review extortion form.
Yes, and it helps guests book without leaving your site. Show a live score from a named platform with the number of reviews behind it, and make sure any quotes you feature reflect what guests say overall. Selecting only the best reviews can count as publishing reviews in a misleading way under UK law.